I am incredibly picky with sunscreens for my little one. This is the first sunscreen with healthy ingredients I've tried that doesn't leave a white cast. Every minute saved when you have a 3 year old is a blessing, applying can be a struggle when your kid squiggle like a worm and gets impatient. I have been satisfied with Caribbean Solutions too, but it is a lot thicker, harder to spread and does leave you looking semi-ghostly (like all the other "natural" sunscreens I've tried) . This one applies like a dream. The scent is very flowery, not the vanilla I expected, but smells wonderful none the less. Extremely expensive for such a tiny amount, but if your wallet allows it I urge you to just get this and not waste your time on all the others!